My question is, what’s the Jewish viewpoint on having a pet like a dog in the house? 


So the question is also what’s the Jewish viewpoint about eating lukshen? And the answer is that there’s no Jewish viewpoint. You want the Jewish viewpoint on every petty issue? So I’ll tell you. The Jewish viewpoint about eating macaroni is it should be kosher, that’s all. And you have to make a brochah. 

However, I must tell you one thing about pets. They shouldn’t be a nuisance to other people! That’s a Jewish viewpoint. If you learn gemara, you learned that if you have a dog that always remains politely behind the fence but then when people go by, your dog rushes up to the fence and gives a loud bark and their hearts stop beating for a moment, then you have to worry about your Olam Habah. That’s the Jewish viewpoint. And such a thing, if you didn’t learn gemara you’d never know it.

There’s a gemara about that (see Bava Kama 79b, 83a). You have to be careful that your animal should not frighten people. Here’s a man who has a dog and when you pass by, the dog starts growling and you walk by apprehensively, nervously. You’re worried – you’re thinking, “Who knows? Maybe he’ll tear my trousers.” And sometimes he does!  A rabbi, a neighbor of mine in East Flatbush, had his trousers torn by a dog. I was bitten by a dog too! I called the police. And I was cursed out by the owner for calling them. He said, “My dog is helpful.” His dog is helpful! Helpful?! That means, “Here, you can enjoy a bite from my dog; it’s worth it because he’s helpful.” A meshugeneh! 

An Orthodox Jew is the only one who knows about what it means to own a dog, how responsible you have to be. Of course, there are Orthodox Jews who are ignorant as well. But they’re not Orthodox; they’re not Orthodox enough. If you didn’t learn, or even if you did, but you don’t practice, then you’re not an Orthodox Jew enough. Because really it’s only the Orthodox Jews, the real ones, who know what it means to prevent injury to your fellow man.

TAPE # 204 (January 1978)

By |2023-07-07T14:51:34+08:00April 4, 2022|Q & A|0 Comments

About the Author: